O Security Through Obscurity

Conversely, removing these headers confuses the scanner or worm and adds extra steps to attackers' endeavors, requiring human interaction, and usually means that automated scanning and attack mechanisms will fail. Before attackers can actually make any headway on exploiting the service and gaining control of the box, they first have to identify the exact service.

Security through obscurity has received a bad name, mainly because it is often the only security performed. However, it can and should have a place as a defense-in-depth mechanism. Too many instances have occurred where the only security has been the belief that because nobody knows how it works, it must be safe. Although this is obviously an inherently flawed concept, security through obscurity has its place—when used in combination with other more aggressive and preventative security measures, it can be a very useful tool.

Part of the process of security through obscurity involves removing or obfuscating headers. Most network services contain headers to politely identify themselves, and sometimes the operating systems they run on, to remote users. This is not necessarily a vulnerability, but it provides unnecessary information and could possibly be used by malicious individuals for nefarious purposes.

Now that you know why header obfuscation is important, we'll discuss the various ways of implementing it. As with anything security related, there is more than one way to do it. There are two main schools of thought on this topic.

The first is to change the header to some enigmatic message or remove it entirely. This accomplishes the goal of obfuscating the true identity of the service but makes it obvious that the header has been modified. Although this may be better than having the service report its default value, it does not create any quality disinformation for scanners and script kiddies to hit on. Also, for more experienced attackers, obfuscating the header is equivalent to a tease, and they will probably feel more motivated than before to identify the service.

The second method is to rename the service to an equivalent but different service. For instance, rename Microsoft IIS to indicate that it is a Netscape Web Server. This method is preferred. It provides more than a little satisfaction when viewing logs and seeing that an attacker tried to run IIS exploits on an Apache server or seeing the attacker was similarly duped on another service. This method is also preferred over the enigmatic message as most attackers will accept at face value the default message indicated by the header, whereas they might be inspired to look a little bit deeper if they encounter an enigmatic message, as it has obviously been changed.

You can use the mod_headers module to change Apache headers. This module makes new options available in the Apache httpd.conf file: Header and ErrorHeader. By configuring both of these directives, using the set argument in the main server configuration section of httpd.conf, the server will send a customized server header value with all HTTP responses:

Header set Server "Microsoft-IIS/6.0" ErrorHeader set Server "Microsoft-IIS/6.0"

Changing these headers is part of making attackers work for every bit of information they obtain. As standard operating procedure, never give anything away. Allow attackers every opportunity to become discouraged, to give up, and to go away. Changing the headers also conveys the message to attackers that the respective systems are not "low-hanging fruit" or easy prey.

Was this article helpful?

0 0
The Ultimate Computer Repair Guide

The Ultimate Computer Repair Guide

Read how to maintain and repair any desktop and laptop computer. This Ebook has articles with photos and videos that show detailed step by step pc repair and maintenance procedures. There are many links to online videos that explain how you can build, maintain, speed up, clean, and repair your computer yourself. Put the money that you were going to pay the PC Tech in your own pocket.

Get My Free Ebook


Post a comment